|
|
Artistic impression of the epic spectacle of Battle of Red Cliff,
erroneously depicting the iconic junk rig, which probably hadn't been
invented during Three Kingdoms period.
|
For the most part, the appearance and designs of Chinese oared warships is
still a matter of debate and conjecture, as to date no Chinese oared warship
of any kind has been found. Information about Chinese oared warships has to be
gleaned from studying written records, crude woodblock prints of military
treatises, as well as shipwrecks of civilian vessels and ocean-going junks.
Still, there is still much unknown about Chinese oared warships, and hopefully
future archaeological finds can shed more light on this subject.
Common types of Chinese oared warships
The list of warships below is mainly taken from Tang period military treatise
Tai Bai Yin Jing (《太白陰經》), as well as Song period military treatise Wu
Jing Zong Yao (《武經總要》) that referenced the former. Although some warships
included in the list like Lou Chuan and Meng Chong have remained a staple of
pre-modern Chinese navies for centuries, the list probably only reflects the
inventory of eighth century Chinese navy but not any other periods. In fact,
there are perhaps dozens if not more Chinese oared warships found in written
records that did not conform to any of the listed classes.
Lou Chuan (樓船, lit. 'Tower ship')
|
|
Illustration of a Lou Chuan, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
Lou Chuan was the greatest of the mainline combat vessels, often serving as
the flagship or centrepiece of ancient Chinese navies. A formidable warship
both at range and up close, Lou Chuan was installed with crenellated bulwark
as well as a three-storey (or more) tall, felt/rawhide-covered wooden
superstructure, complete with battlements and assorted arrow loops and
spear-holes. Thanks to its enormous size, it was capable of mounting shipborne
artillery and other heavier equipment, including traction trebuchets, furnaces
of molten iron,
heavy rocks
and naphtha flamethrowers.
For all its impressive power, Lou Chuan was not without drawbacks, as the
warship's enormous size and high centre of gravity made it particularly
difficult to handle during rough weather and high winds.
Meng Chong (蒙衝)
|
|
Illustration of a Meng Chong, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
Meng Chong was an interesting warship that seems to went through numerous
iterations over the ages, resulting in a number of wildly different warships
all sharing the same name. First mentioned in Eastern Han period dictionary
Shi Ming (《釋名》), Meng Chong in its earliest iteration was simply described
as a ship with long and slender hull specialised in launching assault or
perhaps ram enemy vessel, without any reference to size. Nevertheless, it can
be ascertained that at least by late Eastern Han period, Meng Chong had grown
into enormous juggernaut capable of carrying hundreds of combatants, to the
point that its name effectively became a metonymy for big and formidable
warship.
During Three Kingdoms period, Meng Chong superseded Lou Chuan of the Han
Dynasty to become one of the mainline combat vessels of Eastern Wu navy
alongside the then newly introduced Dou Jian, possibly due to Eastern Wu's prior
bad experience with Lou Chuan capsizing during storm. Though still fairly large,
Eastern Wu's Meng Chong appeared to be more sensibly sized and retained
respectable speed, as several Meng Chong were converted to fire ships during the
famous
Battle of Red Cliffs.
Nevertheless, a new Meng Chong came into prominence during Eastern
Jin period. Rather than a metonymy, the new Meng Chong was a distinct class of
warship, small and agile and came with a fully enclosed hull covered in felt and
rawhide. Though well-protected and equipped with numerous arrow-loops and
spear-holes, this Meng Chong was probably too small to be of any real use during
a serious boarding action (a Tang period example only had a crew of thirty-two
oarsmen and twenty-five marines), and thus it was not considered a mainline
combat vessel. On the flip side, the small warship was well-suited for launching
unconventional attacks, either swarming enemy vessels and harassing them with
arrows, or ramming and delivering incendiary weapons at point-blank range. To
this end, it was often equipped with disproportionately heavy or devastating
weapons, such as heavy
multiprod siege crossbows
or molten iron.
Curiously, both types of Meng Chong appeared to
coexist for a long time, at least until the small Meng Chong was eventually
phased out (although its role was later taken up by other types of warships).
Dou Jian (鬥艦, lit. 'Fighting ship')
|
|
Illustration of a Dou Jian, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
Dou Jian, less commonly known as
Zhan Jian (戰艦, lit. 'Battle ship'),
was a mainline combat vessel first introduced during Three Kingdoms period. A
fairly large warship (although generally smaller than Lou Chuan), Dou Jian was
also installed with crenellated bulwark, although it only had a elevated
fighting platform called
Lou Peng (樓棚, lit. 'Shed', although
hoarding
is a more apt translation) in place of the fortified superstructure of Lou
Chuan.
Based on written descriptions, the fighting platform of Dou Jian appeared
somewhat similar to
balai
platform commonly found on later period Nusantaran warships such as
Ghali, in that they were both fully open structures with a flat roof serving as
fighting platform. Nevertheless, whereas balai left all soldiers on the platform
completely exposed to facilitate boarding action, Lou Peng's roof was
well-protected by a battlement, making it more useful as a missile platform.
Interestingly,
most illustrations of Dou Jian in Chinese military treatises depict the ship
with a fully enclosed, one-storey tower with battlemented roof. While It is
likely that some Dou Jian were indeed built as "one-storey Lou Chuan", another
plausible explanation is that the base level of Lou Peng was only enclosed with
large shields or free-standing wooden panels similar to
Chinese-style hoarding.
Zou Ge (走舸, lit. 'Walking ship')
|
|
Illustration of a Zou Ge, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
Zou Ge was the smallest of the mainline combat vessels of ancient Chinese
navies. Like its larger cousins, Zou Ge was also installed with crenellated
bulwark to protect its passengers, but did not have any superstructure built
on its main deck. Zou Ge was specifically designed for speed and
maneuverability, and was generally assigned more oarsmen than marines,
although these tend to be veterans and elites. Small enough to be towed into
battle behind a larger ship, Zou Ge served a role akin to cavalry or elite
reserve force in a land army, either launching decisive flanking attack after
a battle was already joined (i.e. when two lines of warships clashed and
engaged in boarding action), or reinforcing weak points in the battleline.
Hai Hu (海鶻, lit. 'Sea hawk or sea grebe')
|
|
Illustration of a Hai Hu, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
A relatively late addition first introduced during Tang period, Hai Hu was a
mainline combat ship designed for rough water conditions that might give
troubles to other warships. It had a specifically adapted hull with narrow bow
and low sheer forward and wide stern with high sheer aft, as well as equipped
with a pair of
Fu Bang (浮板, lit. 'Floating plank'), or
leeboards. These features suggest that Hai Hu was designed with heavy emphasis of
stability in mind.
Like all combat vessels, Hai Hu was also installed with crenellated
bulwark, although its was made of thick cowhide instead of wood. The ship was
otherwise outfitted as a Dou Jian (see above).
You Ting (遊艇, lit. 'Wandering boat')
|
|
Illustration of a You Ting, from 'Gu Jin Tu Shu Ji Cheng
(《古今圖書集成》)'.
|
You Ting was a small, fast boat used by ancient Chinese navies for scouting
and relaying command between larger ships. As scouting vessel, You Ting lacked
a crenellated bulwark, and was only minimally armed.
Curiously, some illustrations depict the boat being propelled by ordinary
oars (pictured above), while others show the boat propelled by
yuloh.
Distinguishing features of Chinese oared warship
Even though Chinese oared warships varied greatly in size, shape, and role,
there were many elements generally shared across most Chinese oared warships.
These distinguishing features not only set them apart from other oared warships,
but also reflect the long naval and shipbuilding traditions, unique military
history and approaches to warfare, as well as technological sophistication of
ancient China.
Junk hull
Though larger and far more sophisticated, the hull of Chinese oared warship
probably grew out of ancient
sampan (舢舨), and still had much in common with its smaller cousin such as the
stereotypical "three board" (i.e. a flat bottom, port and starboard) hull
layout, flat bow and transom, as well as prominent "stern horns" to name but a
few. Primarily designed for riverine warfare, particularly on Yangtze River,
Chinese oared warships were generally keelless, although some later period oared
warships designed to operate in the sea had a keel. Virtually all Chinese
warships were fully decked.
|
|
Close-up photo of Han Dynasty shipwreck "Silk Road No. 1", showing its
mortise and tenon planking.
|
Chinese shipwrights favoured a sturdy locked mortise-and-tenon planking
technique, of which wooden planks were joined together with mortise and
tenon, then locked in place by bamboo or wooden dowels, which were replaced
by iron nails, staples and bolts during later period. Chinese shipwrights
also developed multi-layered planking in the Song Dynasty, which
improved ship durability immensely. Archaeological finds reveal that Yuan
river junks could have up to two layers of bottom planking, whereas Song and
Yuan period ocean-going junks manufactured in Fujian also had additional layers
of hull planking, with one notable find having as many as six layers
of hull planking.
Chinese ships were originally built shell-first, although shipwrights
were quick to figure out a unique frame-first shipbuilding method called
Chuan Ke Fa (船殼法, lit. 'Ship-shell method/hull method') after the
invention of watertight bulkhead, as it was much easier to lay down watertight
bulkheads first and then install planking around them, than vice versa.
The
incredible robustness of junk hull, combined with watertight bulkhead
technology (see below), permitted Chinese shipwrights to construct warships of
incredible size. In fact, it was not unusual for large warships to carry a
crew of nearly a thousand.
Shipbuilding and caulking material
Thanks to the vast geographical reach of China, Chinese ships were built
from a huge variety of woods—a fact used by archaeologists to distinguish
Chinese shipwrecks from shipwrecks of foreign visitors (Korean ships, for
example, were nearly exclusively built from red pine). Most shipbuilding
manerials were locally sourced, although foreign imports played a
supplementary but increasingly important role since Yuan period. Common
Chinese shipbuilding materials included Chinese fir, Chinese red pine,
mulberry, champor, sandalwood, zelkova, Chinese elm, Chinese jujube, Chinese
bean tree, Japanese pagoda tree, champor, lychee,
castanopsis,
Erythrophleum fordii,
nanmu
and many more, although Chinese fir remained the most dominant shipbuilding
wood. Generally, load-bearing parts and equipment that must be subjected to
constant wear and tear, such as anchor and rudder, were made of more durable
woods like elm and Japanese emperor oak, as well as imported wood such as
teak, sal wood and Ceylon ironwood.
Chinese shipwrights also
developed a unique and highly effective caulking material dubbed "Chu-nam
putty". It was a mixture of oakum or bamboo fibres, limestone or shell lime,
as well as tung oil.
Watertight bulkhead
|
|
A Chinese junk ship under construction, with very visible watertight
bulkheads. Photo credit © Huang Liang, 2007.
|
Watertight bulkhead technology was a significant Chinese invention that
greatly enhanced the survivability of Chinese ships. Bulkheads not only
provided lateral structural strength to the hull, but also partitioned the
hull into multiple watertight compartments, thus preventing a breach to one
section of the hull from causing flooding to the entire ship.
So far the earliest archaeological find of watertight bulkhead dates to
Tang period, although written records suggest that the technology may have
existed as early as fifth century AD. The earliest ship that may have been
equipped with watertight bulkhead was a type of four-storey Lou Chuan called
Ba Cao Jian (八槽艦, lit. 'Eight trough warship') built by Eastern Jin
rebel Lu Xun (盧循). The warship was probably so named from the close
resemblance of its compartmentalised hull to a feeding trough.
Sternpost-mounted "true" rudder
|
|
Illustration of a Lou Chuan with its rudder highlighted. From 'Wu Jing
Zong Yao (《武經總要》)'.
|
Rudder was another important Chinese invention that greatly simplified the
steering of the ship, and offered far better control, responsiveness,
efficiency and stability than steering oar. Early adoption of true rudder
gave Chinese warships unprecedented maneuverability, and allowed Chinese
shipwrights to construct huge, heavily built vessels without sacrificing
steerability.
Mast tabernacle
Most oared vessels were equipped with supplementary sails for long distance
travel, and Chinese oared ships were no exception. For fighting vessels,
sails, masts and rigging had to be stripped away and left ashore when a
battle was imminent to minimise their interference with ship-to-ship combat.
Unfortunately, this posed a problem when no friendly port to safe keep the
rigging was available, to say nothing about the hurdles of dismantling and
storing large amount of masts and rigging. Many an oared warship had to make
do with furled sail but upright mast in battle due to lack of friendly port
or time.
|
|
Illustration of a Lou Chuan with its laid down mast highlighted. From
'Wu Jing Zong Yao (《武經總要》)'.
|
During Song period, Chinese shipwrights invented mast tabernacle that
allowed a mast to be laid down and secured horizontally when not in use.
Primarily designed to protect the mast during extreme weather (such as
violent winds breaking the mast), the innovative design also allowed Chinese
ships to sail under bridge and warships to sprang into combat-ready state in
a much shorter time.
Chinese shipwrights taught mast tabernacle technology to their Korean
counterparts in the eleventh century. Hence, similar mast design can be seen
on later period Joseon warships such as
Panokseon
and
Turtle Ship.
Yuloh sculling oar
The
Yuloh, known as
Lu (櫓) or
Yao Lu (搖櫓) in Chinese
language, is a type of large, slightly bend oar originated in China. Designed
to be used with a rowing method misnomed
stern sculling
(even though
yuloh can be mounted on any part of a ship, including its
bow), of which the oar blade never leaves the water, a
Yuloh is
significantly more ergonomically- and energy-efficient than an ordinary oar,
allowing even a single oarsman to propel a heavy ship at considerable speed
without quickly tiring himself out. On the flip side,
Yuloh lacks the
sheer output of an oar's rowing strokes, so it cannot match the high
acceleration and top speed of an oar, especially on light, speedy vessel.
|
|
Illustration of a Lou Chuan with its yuloh highlighted.
Note the oarsmen facing forward. From 'Wu Jing Zong Yao
(《武經總要》)'.
|
The adoption of
yuloh can inform us about some of the design
considerations of ancient Chinese oared warships, as well as their tactics.
For instance, Chinese oared warships were almost certainly more heavily built
and robust, but slower than equivalent-sized oared warships of other cultures
such as Mediterranean galley, due to the use of
yuloh. Moreover, even
the mightiest Chinese oared warship only had a single bank of oars, due to the
fact that oarsmen took up a lot of vertical space (as
yuloh is usually
sculled standing up) which prevented them from being arranged into multiple
levels/banks. Fortunately, the freed space in turn allowed Chinese warships to
carry a larger contingent of dedicated combatants or more siege engines. Last
but not least, since
yuloh mounted on Chinese warships jutted downwards
rather than fanning out like oars on galleys, this allowed Chinese warships to
navigate narrower channels and form into denser formations.
Crenellated bulwark
|
|
Illustration of a Lou Chuan with its crenellated bulwark highlighted.
From 'Wu Jing Zong Yao (《武經總要》)'.
|
Unlike warships of other cultures which were only equipped with railings, simple, uncrenellated
bulwarks, or shield lists, Chinese shipwrights routinely installed crenellated bulwarks to the sides of their warships, making this often overlooked and underappreciated feature truly unique to Chinese oared warships.
While the purpose of the battlement is obvious enough, the reason why
Chinese shipwrights specifically went out of their way to install crenellation
on bulwarks can only be speculated. The simplest reason is that this was due
to Chinese naval doctrine placing heavier emphasis on missiles, although there
might be another explanation, namely protection of oarsmen. To elaborate,
since oarsmen sculled
yuloh standing up making them easy targets for
enemy missiles, Chinese warships required higher-than-usual bulwarks to
protect oarsmen from danger. However, this would result in bulwarks of
excessive height that obstruct the view, so it was necessary for crenels to be
cut into the bulwarks to allow marines to fight behind them effectively.